The Canonization of Tim Russert by NBC - Instablogs
The Canonization of Tim Russert by NBC
Going LikeSixty , Monkey: Jun 16 2008
Made Popular Jun 16 2008
United States :

When push comes to shove, Tim Russert was not an important man outside of his family. He was a reporter who appeared on network television. He died.

NBC called him a “giant” in journalism and the world of politics. A giant? Like Edward R. Murrow? Like Benjamin Franklin? Like Mike Wallace? and others of similar ilk who were groundbreakers.

Russert didn’t break any new ground in journalism.

NBC went nuts on Nightly News. Devoting their entire newscast to praising Russert. Mike Barnicle of the Boston Globe referred to him as “Timmy” fer chrissakes. And then he teared up.

Sally Quinn compared his death to John F. Kennedy’s death! She felt special because Tim was praying for her when a family tragedy stuck. Pope Russert?

ABC was similar in their glowing tribute. I didn’t watch CBS.

Other people died that same day. People who impacted a LOT of people’s lives in a positive and authentic way. Tim Russert was a high visibility TV personality.

It was way overplayed by the networks.

He was not irreplaceable.

It’s inside-the-beltway mentality at it’s worst!
The Canonization of Tim Russert by NBC

The National Press Club got it right…

“Tim was a colleague and friend to all in journalism. He was a role model for all of us, whether in print or broadcast. Tim epitomized excellence in journalism and unflinching commitment to the craft. Our profession has lost a stellar journalist.”

Hyperbole. Over and over and over. Why did Russert have to die at the beginning of the weekend when news is slow?
Can we be far from St. Tim of Buffalo?

Most bigwigs have settled into a “he was a great journalist” reaction after the spinmeisters have had a chance to sleep on it, but NBC is still mourning every change they get.

But their still are a few who are just nuts.

Barbara Walters: “There is no one who knew Tim, and that includes millions of Americans who felt they knew him too, who isn’t deeply shocked and saddened by his death. Tim was everyone’s idea of what a journalist should be and he made us proud. He interviewed me just one month ago for his weekly television show and much of our conversation had to do with his love for his father, Russ, and his son, Luke.”

Millions who felt they knew him? Does she have such little respect for our intellect to think that we believe people on TV are really like their on-air personna? Apparently so. “he interviewed me… and much of the conversation was about…” his dad and son. Which was is BaBa? I thought the interviewer listened to the person being interviewed. She needs to retire to The View permanently.

Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi: “Today, broadcast journalism lost one of its giants, who will be remembered along with names like Edward R. Murrow, Walter Cronkite, and David Brinkley.”

Oh, puh-leeze to put him in the same category as those people is just ludicrous. Absolutely laughable.

In the big scheme of things Tim Russert was Just. Not. That. Important. He was a pundit.

Sunday’s Meet the Press showed an empty chair where Russert normally would have parked. NBC’s version of the riderless horse cortege. Perhaps the white board should have been draped in black fabric.

Conan O’Brien got the memo. His late night COMEDY show paid their tribute. Looks like if you’re NBC you pay tribute. During the golf tournament Saturday and Sunday on NBC, they took time to pay more tribute… Golf? Russert?

The Today show on Monday was suitably maudlin and morose.

Will this continue through his burial? One can only hope that it ends there.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
0 Stars
Kim publiuspundit.com/
New York, United States
Russert was a hard core left-wing idealogue pretending to be something else. He was part of the ultra left-wing administration of Mario Cuomo and then served the bidding of the Democrats in the U.S. Senate. To think that he suddenly, magically became an objective ”journalist” by going on TV is laughably insane.
0 Stars
Rudolf irokoproductions.com
New York, United States
Going,

Common now, let them mourn. If you cannot stand it, switch off.

I personally have watched him every Sunday for eight years or more. His death was a big loss to me too. And there is nobody in journalism today that I look forward to watching the way I looked forward to watching Tim. He is one of the greatest ever. Maybe you don’t know him because you don’t watch him or you allowed the fact that you shared the same time in history with him to minimize in your mind his importance. 50 years from now, when the Olbermanns, the O’Reillys and the Hannitys have taken over the world of journalism then you will appreciate the greatness of Tim.

This is what Rush Limbaugh said about Tim Russert. ”It’s just a shame. Tim was a regular guy with that perpetual smile he wore naturally all the time. He loved life and got everything he could out of it. Whether it was at dinner here in Florida while his son was taking golf lessons, or on the set of Meet The Press, Tim was always the same with me: genuine. He never condescended to anyone and was the consummate professional. He will be hard to replace. He was the closest thing there was at any of the networks to an objective journalist.”

If Rush could be this generous, who the angle are you to grumble?

The greatest quote I heard on his death was from a comment a friend of mine made. He said, “why didn’t death see the likes of Rush Limbaugh or Bill O’Reilly or that mad man, Sean Hannity.”

Well, we cannot command death. And we cannot decide for others how they are going to mourn their colleague. We have a wonderful option – to switch channels.
1 Stars
@Rudolf:
I did not change channels of Nightly News because I could not believe they would devote the entire program to Russert.

I did not watch any of the tributes. I heard the promos for them. Why would I watch? Why would I care.\
Some were unavoidable - the golf game cut-ins, but I did mute them.

Again: in the big picture - he was only important to his family.

The world is the same without him - he made no lasting contribution to making the world better.

Since when do we allow the public airways to be used for catharsis?
1 Stars
Aparna
Mumbai, India
In a world where television journalism is increasingly dictated by corporate and political agendas, Russert was refreshingly tough, fair, and balanced as a journalist. If anyone has had the mind-numbing experience of watching local TV in the States, they will be aware of the complete minimization of critical analysis and investigative journalism that is the hallmark of domestic programming. In this context, Russert did what few serious journalists would have attempted - report, question, and analyse well beyond the superficial. It was for this that he received respect of his peers, an immense following, and the admiration even of his interviewees who reportedly vied for spots on his show.
1 Stars
@Aparna: I agree with what you said ...and that was his job.

He did an excellent job. No more. No less. But so what? What will his departure from this world mean?
Nada, zilch, nothing.

How was the world better with him in it?

This is my basic point: that he does not deserve on the ongoing adulation from NBC and insiders.

CNBC will carry his memorial service LIVE!

This is ridiculous!
1 Stars
Aparna
Mumbai, India
And my point in the comment above is that he did make a difference. There are not many like him in the world of journalism - and his going does mean a loss. It is because fewer and fewer are willing to speak out that he has become a hero of the people. In other words - his was not just a job. Whatever else he may or may not deserve, he does deserve some respect - even by those who choose to minimise him. Every human is entitled to dignity both in life and after.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
@Arpna: I am not disrespecting the man.

I am disrespecting NBC for going way over the top in covering his death.

Hero of the people? No. Questioning the insiders is not EVER heroic. NEVER.

NBC is giving his life/death hours and hours and hours of network and cable coverage.

When Peter Jennings died, ABC did maybe a couple hours.

As TV critic said, NBC is giving his death coverage like the Pope or President dying or the Challenger explosion.

NBC is the villian here. Not Tim Russert
Add your Comment